Is Elon Musk's Neuralink technology a good idea?


Fact Box

  • Elon Musk is a South African-born American immigrant who is the CEO/founder of several companies, including the electric car maker Tesla, rocket producer Space X, the infrastructure-building Boring Company, and Neuralink. He co-founded Open AI in 2015, the producers of ChatGPT and DALL-E. Musk purchased Twitter, later rebranded as X, in 2022 for almost $44 billion. As of February 2024, his net worth is around $200 billion.
  • Neuralink is an American neurotechnology corporation based in Fremont, California, and founded in 2016 with the goal of creating implantable brain-computer interfaces.
  • In January 2024, Neuralink implanted its first human subject, whom Musk reported was “recovering well.” In interviews, he has expressed how the goal of this technology is to help those who have “lost their limbs” or other functionality.
  • A 2023 YouGov Poll on Musk found that 53% of Americans view him favorably while 37% do not.

Mark (No)

Not only does Elon Musk's Neuralink technology need to be clarified, but it's also markedly dangerous. There is a whole range of concerns when considering this sort of tech, such as ethics and privacy, security risks, the fact that it requires invasive brain surgery and that there is no long-term health data on what this could do to humans. There are simply more questions than answers regarding Neuralink, which is perhaps intentional. We can deduce that the developers still don't completely grasp what they are trying to achieve. With something this sensitive and controversial, any potential discrepancies are simply unacceptable. Those who have worked for Neuralink in the past have come to speak out against it.

They have described Neuralink as both 'invasive' and 'dangerous.' Neuralink imposes the dangers associated with AI that many scientists and researchers have warned about. Having a chip literally implanted into your head would pose countless threats, many of them fatal. The chip could be manipulated and, in the wrong hands, would be nothing short of catastrophic. Likewise, the procedure required to implant the chip is potentially harmful, with many controversial considerations

Unquestionably, the most egregious aspect of this technology is the animal testing that was conducted, which resulted in the deaths of over a dozen monkeys. The monkeys reacted to the Neuralink chip negatively, with both self-harm and paralysis observed, before they ultimately perished. Needless to say, this sort of technology could see human subjects react in the same way. It could potentially trigger memory responses that relate to trauma and anxiety, causing unimaginable consequences.

Rob (Yes)

Neuralink technology has faced a lot of skepticism and criticism, owing to concerns about the possible downsides to this technology and partly because of the person behind it. However, it's more important to look at it in the light of the good it's capable of and how it would change lives for the better. 

For starters, Neuralink technology has the potential to revolutionize the medical industry. It could open new avenues for the treatment of neurological disorders such as autism, Schizophrenia, Parkinson's disease, epilepsy, as well as spinal cord issues. The chip being directly linked to the brain makes it easy to extract valuable data for research into the brain, possibly leading to breakthroughs in neuroscience and other related fields. It also makes developing more personalized healthcare solutions for specific cases easier.

Additionally, Neuralink technology could be a game changer for people with disabilities. For example, it could enable those with prosthetic limbs to control them directly with their minds. It could allow people with hearing disabilities to relay information telepathically without signing. Blind people could also have images artificially broadcasted into their brains, significantly improving the quality of life for these individuals. 

Likewise, this technology also has the potential to enhance the cognitive abilities of a person, almost like adding a powerful processor to a computer. It could improve their problem-solving skills and augment their memory and learning abilities. The 21st century is all about autonomy and progress—there’s no better or exciting way to give people complete control over their bodies and minds.

  • chat-ic0
  • like-ic3
  • chart-ic35
  • share-icShare


0 / 1000